Skip to content

Why Didn't They Ask Evans?

Pages
252
Published
1935
Language
English

Synopsis

A round of golf at a Welsh seaside resort takes a grim turn when Bobby Jones, the easygoing fourth son of the vicar of Marchbolt, slices a ball over a cliff and discovers a man broken on the rocks below. The stranger lives just long enough to murmur a single baffling question before he dies, and that question lodges itself in Bobby's mind. When an inquest swiftly closes the matter as an accident, Bobby is inclined to let it rest, until an attempt is made on his own life and the loose threads refuse to lie flat. Joined by his spirited childhood friend Lady Frances Derwent, known to everyone as Frankie, he sets out to make sense of the dying words and the curious people who seem connected to them. The two adopt disguises, stage a motor accident to gain entry to a suspicious household, and trade quick banter as the stakes climb from idle curiosity toward genuine peril. Wit and recklessness carry them where caution would not, and their amateur sleuthing brushes against forces far more dangerous than either anticipated. Working without a famous detective to guide them, Bobby and Frankie must rely on nerve, luck, and each other. Set among country houses, a nursing home, and the cliffs of the Welsh coast, the story moves at a brisk pace, balancing genuine menace with a light, conversational charm and a puzzle that keeps circling back to one teasing question.

About the author

A
Agatha Christie

Dame Agatha Christie (1890-1976) is the best-selling novelist of all time and the writer the world calls the "Queen of Crime." Born Agatha Miller in Torquay, Devon, she came to fiction on a dare: her sister Madge bet she could not write a convincing detective story, and the result, The Mysterious Affair at Styles, introduced the Belgian detective Hercule Poirot. Her dispensing work in a hospital pharmacy during the First World War, repeated again during the Second, gave her the expert knowledge...

Characters

Bobby JonesProtagonist

The amiable, unambitious fourth son of the vicar of Marchbolt who finds the dying man and becomes drawn into the investigation.

Lady Frances "Frankie" DerwentProtagonist

Bobby's spirited, well-born childhood friend whose social standing and daring drive much of the amateur detective work.

Robert "Bobby" JonesProtagonist

A young vicar's son and amateur sleuth who finds a dying man on the golf course and becomes obsessed with solving his identity.

Alan CarstairsSupporting

The traveller and big-game hunter found dying at the foot of the cliff, whose last words set the mystery in motion.

Roger Bassington-ffrenchSupporting

A charming younger brother in the Bassington-ffrench household whom Frankie contrives to meet during the inquiry.

All characters in Why Didn't They Ask Evans?

Frequently asked questions

  • Why does the book have two different titles?

    Collins Crime Club published it in Britain as Why Didn't They Ask Evans? in September 1934. In the United States, Dodd, Mead and Company issued it in 1935 under the title The Boomerang Clue.

  • What does the title "Why didn't they ask Evans?" refer to?

    It is the dying question spoken by the man Bobby Jones finds at the foot of a cliff. Making sense of that single tantalising clue becomes the central puzzle that drives the entire investigation.

  • Does this novel feature one of Agatha Christie's famous detectives like Poirot or Miss Marple?

    No. The book is a standalone with no recurring Christie sleuth, and the case is solved by two amateur detectives. The investigators are the vicar's son Bobby Jones and his friend Lady Frances "Frankie" Derwent.

  • How does Bobby Jones become involved in the mystery?

    While playing golf at a Welsh seaside resort, Bobby slices his ball over a cliff and finds a dying man on the rocks below. The man's final words set Bobby, and later Frankie, on the trail of a murder.

  • Did the 2009 ITV Marple series adapt this book even though Miss Marple is not in it?

    Yes. The 2009 Agatha Christie's Marple episode inserted Miss Marple as the lead investigator despite her not appearing in the original novel. The series frequently reworked Christie's non-Marple stories this way, a choice that drew criticism for sidelining the book's young amateur sleuths.

  • Is there a recent screen adaptation of this story?

    Yes. A three-part miniseries written and directed by Hugh Laurie aired on BritBox in April 2022. It stars Will Poulter as Bobby Jones and Lucy Boynton as Frankie Derwent, with a cast that includes Emma Thompson and Jim Broadbent.

  • Where is the story set?

    The action begins at the Welsh coastal town of Marchbolt where the body is found, then moves to country houses and a nursing home in Hampshire as the investigation widens. The cliffs of the Welsh coast frame the opening discovery.

  • What kind of mystery is it in tone?

    It is a light, fast-moving adventure-mystery built on the banter and daring of its two amateur sleuths rather than a methodical detective procedural. The comic energy of Bobby and Frankie's partnership runs alongside moments of real danger.