M. L. RioMystery · Thriller
If We Were Villains
Synopsis
Ten years after his release from prison for a murder he may or may not have committed, Oliver Marks agrees to finally tell a retired detective what really happened during his final year at Dellecher Classical Conservatory. There, a tight-knit group of seven Shakespearean acting students lived and breathed the plays they performed, casting themselves in the same types of roles — hero, villain, temptress — until the lines between the stage and their own lives began to blur.
When a shift in casting upends the group's fragile hierarchy, old resentments and desires that had simmered for years boil over into something none of them can take back. As the group's charismatic, self-destructive dynamics spiral toward tragedy, one of them ends up dead — and the story Oliver has spent a decade not telling finally comes out, unreliable narrator and all.
M. L. Rio's atmospheric dark-academia debut is steeped in Shakespeare, using long passages of the plays themselves to narrate a story of obsession, jealousy, and the danger of actors who can no longer tell where their characters end and they begin.
How it reads
Prose complexity 7/10
Content warnings (2)
ViolenceSubstance Abuse
- Una de mis grandes quejas, y decepciones, con este libro es que no es un thiller, sino más bien un drama juvenil. Sí, juvenil, porque, aunque los personajes tengan entre 20 y 22 años, se comportan como si tuvieran 15. Un tanto decepcionante, pero al menos es entretenido. También tengo la sensación de que la autora ha querido añadir de manera forzada una subtrama gay entre Oliver y James para apelar a este público tan obsesivo, cuando es obvio que a Oliver le atrae Meredith y a James, Wren. Y que la crítica de muchos se reduzca a “no es lo suficientemente gay” y a las quejas de que haya parejas heterosexuales me parece patético por parte de esa gente. Dicho esto, paso a mis opiniones sobre el libro en sí. La historia no empieza mal y la premisa pintaba interesante. Te hace pensar que algo grave ha ocurrido entre estos amigos: una verdadera tragedia como las que interpretan, en parte por cómo fue vendido (literalmente, en la portada pone “cuando los amigos se convierten en enemigos” y “no hay límites para el daño que pueden hacer”, pero adivina qué, ni los amigos se convierten en enemigos ni hay límites que traspasan para hacer ese daño que sugiere la frase). Pero la trama del libro no se centra en el asesinato, sino en el drama de los personajes. Un thriller se ha de centrar en el crimen y el misterio, pero este no lo hace. De ahí que no sea un thriller. El crimen pasa a un tercer plano y no se onda en ello. Además, para el final de la segunda parte (llamado acto en esta novela), el lector ya sabe quién es el asesino, por qué Oliver está en la cárcel pese a no ser el culpable, quién es la víctima y dónde ha ocurrido el crimen. Queda el por qué, pero es irrelevante cuando se sabe quién es el asesino en la segunda parte, dejando las otras tres aburridas que, realmente, no aportan nada salvo tratar el drama de los personajes. Hay ciertas cosas ya desde el inicio que te hace pensar que el libro fue escrito por una adolescente más que por una adulta: las descripciones tan cómicas rollo anime de los personajes (y ciertos actos que hacen), el uso de paréntesis cuando no son necesarios (literalmente pone una frase entera entre paréntesis cuando podría ser una frase normal dentro del propio párrafo), el uso de frases enteras en mayúsculas para enfatizar que están gritando, cosa que no es necesario porque para eso existen los símbolos de exclamación, y el uso constante de palabras en cursiva. Son cosas sin sentido que podría haber solucionado de manera muy fácil. Ahora, ir intercalando entre diálogo “normal” y uno de teatro resulta interesante. ¿Innecesario? Sí. ¿Interesante? También. También puedo entender que a la gente le moleste que estén citando a Shakespeare todo el rato, pero lo veo normal. Como Oliver dice, ese colegio es como una secta. Cada grupo de alumno vive en una burbuja de su materia a la que se abandonan y se dedican al 100%. La de ellos es Shakespeare. Que lo citen todo el rato refuerza ese sentimiento que expresa Oliver de que vivían en una burbuja, esa “pérdida de la realidad” de la que habla al interpretar constantemente personajes de Shakespeare, pues como dice Meredith, ahí todos fingen ser personajes de ficción. No son ellos mismos. Esas citaciones refuerzan eso. Lo veo bien. La manera de escribir de la autora no es la mejor pero tampoco la peor. La autora escribe bien, pero le falta práctica. Eso se puede pulir. Una queja que tengo es que, como autora de “thriller”, no puedes hacer que el lector adivine todo (las Cinco W -Qué, Quién, Cuándo, Dónde, Por qué y Cómo) al final de la segunda parte cuando aún quedan tres partes más. Un gran bajón. Sin mencionar que la parte en donde Oliver vuelve a casa es totalmente innecesaria y aburre, pues no aporta nada a la trama. Los personajes… ni fu ni fa. Son muy estereotipados, aunque eso no es necesariamente malo, pero en este casi sí lo es, pues se comportan de una manera errática y para nada agradable. No se puede empatizar con ninguno de ellos, ni con el protagonista, Oliver. Son personajes vacíos, sin mucha complejidad (aunque tenían el potencial para ser grandes personajes), sosos e insípidos. En general, son muy aburridos. Todos. Y un gran error de la autora para justificar el asesinato es hacer al villano, Richard, como el ser más malvado del mundo de la nada, sin ningún propósito, para que su asesino no quede como el malo, pues “mira qué bueno es que ha matado a una horrible persona”. Esa parte es horrible, pues había el potencial para hacer de ello un plot twist muy bueno: “ni el malo es tan malo ni el bueno es tan bueno”, pero no. De nuevo, personajes sosos. En general, no es un libro que recomendaría ni que volvería a leer y, honestamente, creo que ni merezca la pena leer, pues realmente no te aporta nada, pero habiéndolo leído al haber sido engañada de que era un thriller (que no lo es), puedo decir que, al menos, me ha entretenido. Un libro muy meh.
- It's not often that I get to read a book that can strike the soul so deeply. Such is the effect that this book has given me. IF WE WERE VILLAINS embedded itself inside my heart more than I gave it the right to do so and now I don't know what I'm going to do now that everything's over. Reading every line of this book was an experience no less than enthralling and I have no doubt that this book will continue to be in the list of my favorites until my last breath. I can't even properly describe the impression this book made upon me. It has made me even more dramatic than I have ever been in my life. Now I even want to randomly speak in verse even though I don't have the knowledge and the brainpower for that. What charmed me at first was this book's premise. I didn't know much before I started reading except the fact that this one's filled with dramatic theater kids, murder, and mayhem. Upon reading this book, I learned that it's so much more than those things. What's alluring about this book is the way casual lines are thrown around and they land with a punch, giving a sense of thrill to the reader to find out what's going to happen next. The sense of anticipation and suspense that I felt while reading this book kept me on the edge of my seat and made me ask for more. It was not even remotely suspenseful at first, but I can feel the chaos bubbling up the surface and I couldn't help but turn the pages until I could find out more. The next winning factor of this book was its characters. Oliver, James, Wren, Fillipa, Alexander, Meredith, and Richard all seemed larger than life. If We Were Liars is so chatacter-driven with a feeling of rawness to it that sucked me in so deep. Their relationships, feelings, and thoughts feel both simple and complicated at the same time. To use Colborne's word, I am drastically ENAMORED with them all and their dynamics intrigue and fascinate me to no end (James and Oliver most intriguing of all). There's so much feeling and connection between all of them, like threads tightly woven together. The characterization of everyone here is one of a kind and I don't doubt that I will forever be fond of it. IF WE WERE VILLAINS is a harrowing tale of emotions and mystery, with a lot of Shakespeare sprinkled everywhere. I have no interest in poetry or plays whatsoever but reading this book was both gratifying and haunting— an experience I will never forget.
- -- Reread July 24, 2025-- James and Oliver forever and ever. --- Literally all the stars? How do I even review a book this good? James and Oliver will all the crevices of my heart. —Review Updated 2/16– Secrets carry weight. Like Lead. If We Were Villains by ML Rio 5/5 Stars I’m a big fan of going into books as blind as I can, and I’m so happy that I did with this one. This follows Oliver as he is released from prison for a crime he may or may not have committed. Upon his release, he recounts the story of what happened to the detective who arrested him. I think it’s very important to know that I was a theater kid in middle school and high school - so to say there were parts of this book that resonated and woke something that I had been missing is very, very true. I feel inadequate to review this without giving too much of the plot away. The twists, turns and reveals were so good. I was on the edge of my seat for most of the book and felt genuine anxiety for all of the characters. I’ll love Oliver and Felix forever - they are definitely the type of characters that stick with you in the long run. I funnily enough also played Benvolio in my middle school rendition of R&J, and the way Oliver feels about being the side character is so endearingly relatable.
- <div>What a great book! <br>I liked it sooo much and it's beautifully written 😍 But it was kind of a harder read — because of the topics and because of the vocabulary 😅😂 <br>It started a little bit slow, and the pace is in general slower than the books that I normally read, but when you get used to it it's absolutely no problem and you really want to know what happened that night and what happens next. There's also a lot of foreshadowing, what I really liked.<br>I really liked almost all of the characters a lot <spoiler>and I was so sad at the end, because of James 😫😫😫 It was the first time ever that I cried because of a book 😢 But there's still hope 🥹🙏🏼 I'm delusional 😅</spoiler><br>I think that the reading experience could be even better, when you have more knowledge about Shakespeare's works, but you can also read it when you have only a little knowledge — that's totally okay <br><br>But please, check the trigger warnings! There are some heavy topics in this book </div>
- I think I agree with Colborne here: "Honestly, I don’t know. I thought some closure would make it more bearable, but now I’m not so sure." This is what I feel about the ending...
- – “But that is how a tragedy like ours or King Lear breaks your heart—by making you believe that the ending might still be happy, until the very last minute.”
- i enjoyed this book beyond belief. i guess anyone who likes dark academia, this is the book !
- Mad at myself for not reading this sooner! AMAZING book!
- <div>my heart hurts and my soul is wrecked</div>














