Ashley PostonRomance · Contemporary Romance
A Novel Love Story
Synopsis
Eileen "Elsy" Merriweather has weathered heartbreak and loneliness by escaping into Quixotic Falls, her favourite cozy romance series — a comfort made bittersweet by the fact that its author, Rachel Flowers, died before writing the final book. Then, lost on a road trip, Elsy drives into Eloraton, New York, and slowly realises the impossible: she has arrived inside the unfinished series itself.
Eloraton is perfectly, eerily frozen. The candy shop's taffy is always sweet, the bar's burgers are always a little burnt, and rain always falls in the afternoon. Its residents live their half-written stories on a loop, waiting for their happily-ever-afters. The only person who doesn't fit is a grumpy, mint-eyed bookstore owner named Anders — the one character Elsy can't place, and the one person determined to stop her from finishing the book.
A cozy, bookish romance about grief, second chances, and the stories we hide inside, A Novel Love Story is Ashley Poston's love letter to readers who have ever wished they could live in their favourite novel.
How it reads
Prose complexity 4/10
Readers say (1)Whimsical
- <div>I'm sure many people will love this book, but unfortunately, it just wasn't for me. I loved The Dead Romantics and had high expectations for this new book, but sadly, they weren't met.<br><br>The idea of reading about someone who manages to enter the fictional city of their favorite series seemed like a fascinating plot to me—something I would personally love to experience. I started reading with a lot of enthusiasm, but I couldn't connect with the story. I didn’t grow attached to either the real or the fictional characters, and the plot felt slow, simple, and underdeveloped.<br><br>There was no real risk in what Elsy did to the fictional town; her actions didn’t seem to have any significant or dangerous consequences, which would have made things much more interesting. I also didn’t feel the chemistry between the main couple.<br><br>While the ending did regain some interest, it frustrated me because, even though everything gets 'resolved,' Anders' character takes a step back instead of moving forward and confronting his past.<br><br>Honestly, I don't know if I would have finished the book if it hadn't been my book club's pick of the month.</div>
- <div>I have mixed thoughts on this one, loved the author's previous work so went in with so much hope but this one disappointed me. Elsy was too annoying for me at the beginning, got better towards the end but I didn't care then, too late ig? Couldn't connect to both of them actually. Then all the characters in the town were all jumbled up and honestly even by the end I didn't know who's who 😭 I feel like we got too many characters and stories all mixed in and that part of the book felt random at so many moments. Didn't feel connected to any of those characters. Also I know this is a rom-com but at times it felt too idk perfect fairytalish, maybe it was meant to be that way. It had its moments, Elsy and Anders were cute at times and Anders being Rachel's fiance was a nice twist, wasn't expecting that. Five year slip has my heart, wish I could have liked this one more </div>
- <div>Genre: Summer Paranormal Romance 📚🩵</div><div>📍 Tropes/Themes: Cozy Magical Realism; Professor of Literature/Bookstore Owner; Super Smutty Book Club; Small Town; Enemies to Lovers; Forced Proximity; Grumpy/Sunshine; MCs Over 30; Set in New York; Single 1st Person POV</div><div>⚠️CW: death/grief</div><div>🔥: 🌶️🌶️ (cracked door)</div><div>Format: digital 📱</div><div>💭Thoughts: </div><div>Cozy books shouldn’t make my face leak this much 😭 </div><div>I thought I had everything figured out in the first few chapters, and I’m so glad I was so wrong. Everyone was layered so beautifully, the foreshadowing so gotdang clever, and the ending 🥹 so heartwarming. I can’t wait to get a physical copy of this one for my trophy shelf 🏆 </div>
- Genre: Summer Paranormal Romance 📚🩵 | 📍 Tropes/Themes: Cozy Magical Realism; Professor of Literature/Bookstore Owner; Super Smutty Book Club; Small Town; Enemies to Lovers; Forced Proximity; Grumpy/Sunshine; MCs Over 30; Set in New York; Single 1st Person POV | ⚠️CW: death/grief | 🔥: 🌶️🌶️ (cracked door) | Format: digital 📱 | 💭Thoughts: | Cozy books shouldn’t make my face leak this much 😭 | I thought I had everything figured out in the first few chapters, and I’m so glad I was so wrong. Everyone was layered so beautifully, the foreshadowing so gotdang clever, and the ending 🥹 so heartwarming. I can’t wait to get a physical copy of this one for my trophy shelf 🏆
- It was such a wonderful read, loved it from beginning to end. The way we get the romance but also intrigue as to how this all happened. The romance was my favorite part, the way it blossomed and progressed so well through the story. The way our FMC grows due to this adventure and finds her happy ever after.
- Stopped reading once Elsy SLAPPED Anders across the face because she didn't like what he was saying. That's never ok. She immediately apologized, still doesn't make it ok. She was free to walk away. Imagine if the roles were reversed?
- 3.5!! Not my fave, but I think I just don't love books that are set in a book? Is this too meta for me? A fun little story if you're looking for a palette cleanser!
- On pause
- It's always the love that finds you out of nowhere and not the opposite