Skip to content
5.0

-- Reread July 24, 2025--
James and Oliver forever and ever.


Literally all the stars? How do I even review a book this good? James and Oliver will all the crevices of my heart.

—Review Updated 2/16–
Secrets carry weight. Like Lead.

If We Were Villains by ML Rio
5/5 Stars

I’m a big fan of going into books as blind as I can, and I’m so happy that I did with this one.

This follows Oliver as he is released from prison for a crime he may or may not have committed. Upon his release, he recounts the story of what happened to the detective who arrested him.

I think it’s very important to know that I was a theater kid in middle school and high school - so to say there were parts of this book that resonated and woke something that I had been missing is very, very true.

I feel inadequate to review this without giving too much of the plot away. The twists, turns and reveals were so good. I was on the edge of my seat for most of the book and felt genuine anxiety for all of the characters. I’ll love Oliver and Felix forever - they are definitely the type of characters that stick with you in the long run. I funnily enough also played Benvolio in my middle school rendition of R&J, and the way Oliver feels about being the side character is so endearingly relatable.