A
Adam BeckerHistory · Science
What Is Real?
Quantum mechanics is one of the most successful theories in physics, and physicists agree on that much. They do not agree on what it means. This non-fiction history follows the long dispute over what, if anything, lies beneath the mathematics.
For about a century, most physicists have accepted the Copenhagen interpretation associated with Niels Bohr. Under it, questions about the reality behind quantum physics are treated as meaningless. Adam Becker presents Copenhagen as a muddle of solipsism and weak reasoning that survived anyway. Bohr's students defended his legacy hard, and a physics community that preferred practical experiments to philosophical argument let it stand.
The cost fell on those who objected. Challenging the standard view could end a career. The book tells the story of John Bell, David Bohm and Hugh Everett, who kept pressing for an account of what quantum mechanics says about the world, from the 1920s into the present day.
The approach is a history of ideas and of the people who held them, covering a scientific quarrel as well as the professional pressures around it. It suits readers curious about the foundations of physics and about how a scientific orthodoxy protects itself. The tone is partisan toward the dissenters, and the pace is that of a story about a long fight.