We Are All Guilty Here
Characters in We Are All Guilty Here
8 characters, main characters first.Main characters
Emmy Clifton-Lang
A North Falls police officer who blames herself for turning away her best friend's daughter and leads the investigation into the two teenage girls' disappearance.
Supporting characters
Madison Dalrymple
A fifteen-year-old who vanishes with her friend Cheyenne on the night of North Falls' Fourth of July fireworks, after asking Emmy for help.
Cheyenne Baker
Madison's closest friend, who disappears alongside her on the night of the fireworks and turns out to have secrets of her own.
Gerald Clifton
Emmy's father, the longtime sheriff of North Falls, who leads the original investigation into the girls' disappearance.
Hannah Dalrymple
Emmy's close friend and Madison's mother, whose relationship with Emmy is strained by the girl's disappearance.
Cole Lang
Emmy's young son, present at the North Falls fireworks the night the two girls vanish.
Paisley Walker
A teenage girl who disappears from North Falls years after the original case, in circumstances that echo it closely.