Amber SmithYoung Adult · YA Contemporary·b. 1982
The Way I Used To Be
Synopsis
The night Eden is raped by her older brother's best friend, someone she has known and trusted for years, she makes a decision that will shape everything that follows: she tells no one. Convinced that speaking up will destroy her family and that no one would believe her anyway, she buries the truth and, with it, the girl she used to be.
Told across all four years of high school, the novel follows Eden as the person she once was, a shy, obedient band geek, slowly disappears, replaced by someone reckless, angry, and unrecognizable even to herself. She pushes away the people who love her, punishes herself in ways she barely understands, and carries a secret that grows heavier with every passing year.
Amber Smith's raw, unflinching debut is a young adult novel about sexual assault, trauma, and the long, non-linear road toward finding a voice. Difficult and deeply honest, it charts one girl's struggle to reclaim herself and to finally say what happened out loud.
How it reads
- Writing1.0
- Impact5.0
- Characters5.0
- Plot4.0
- Atmosphere4.0
Prose complexity 4/10
Content warnings (4)
Sexual AssaultTraumaSexual ContentSubstance Abuse
- What got me the most was how silent pain was portrayed. The whole pretending-you’re-fine thing, pushing people away, acting like nothing affects you when internally you’re literally falling apart… yeah. That hit a little too close to home at times. I found myself relating to Eden in ways I wasn’t expecting, not necessarily through the exact same experiences, but through the emotions ,the numbness, the anger, the confusion, the feeling of becoming someone you barely recognize. And the writing? So raw. No sugarcoating, no trying to make trauma look “pretty.” It was uncomfortable, heavy, and sometimes honestly hard to read… but in the best way possible. Some chapters genuinely made me stop for a second because damn… that line, that scene, that feeling... it just got it. This isn’t the kind of book you “enjoy” in a fun way. It’s the kind of book you feel. The kind that quietly breaks something in you while also making you feel seen. Definitely not an easy read, but one I’m glad I experienced. 5/5, even if it emotionally wrecked me a little.
- <div>Eden is very unlikeable. </div>
- 3.5/5


