This is a book that you love bc of the “vibes.” Obviously for other reasons too. But I swear it was like I was reading it with one candle in the dark and (friendly) spirits humming in the background. It made me feel cozy, curious, and very witchy, very much in that Practical Magic space. The witchcraft felt grounded in grief, responsibility, and restraint, when needed, rather than superficial sparkle and dazzle, which made me so much more invested.

I loved how the magic and historical context illustrated the gender politics, without being heavy-handed, especially reversing the roles of infertility.. The romance had real yearning and mutual respect, even if both characters resisted their feelings longer than necessary (it got a little repetitive).

But it’s okay, the mystery provided enough pacing to keep the story moving. 4 stars because the emotional revelations outweighed the pacing issues.

Definitely a book to read during October witchy season to get in the spooky mood! Can’t wait to get to the books of the other girls in the coven!

I received an ARC of this book courtesy of NetGalley and the publisher. All opinions expressed in this review are my own and given freely