This was so cute! They actually had good chemistry and great banter. They made a super cute and funny couple. I believe his reaction to her revealing why she didn't like him was realistic.
Expecting him to remember calling her ugly in eighth grade would have been so unrealistic! I liked the way this was handled. He admitted that he very well could have said it. He was also a kid at the time. Her remembering it for this whole time was also realistic. It was a hurtful thing to say and those kinds of things stick with you.
Overall, fun! I wish this was a full length book!!!