Skip to content
5.0

I genuinely loved everything about this book. The atmosphere, the writing, the characters, the humor, the emotional devastation (because apparently I cannot be allowed to enjoy a book without it eventually hurting me). This is exactly the kind of fantasy that reminds me why I love the genre so much.

First of all, let’s talk about the Gentlemen Bastards themselves because WHAT A GROUP OF CHARACTERS. Their dynamic is everything. They feel like a group of people who have spent so much time together that their relationships have developed their own language. They know how to push each other’s buttons, they know when to trust each other, and underneath all the sarcasm and scheming, there is a genuine affection that makes their dynamic so compelling. I could honestly spend an entire review talking about these idiots and still feel like I hadn’t said enough. Their banter added so much soul to the story.

So it’s already obvious that I loved our main character. Locke Lamora is intelligent without being infallible, confident without being invincible, and capable of pulling off elaborate schemes while simultaneously making me want to scream at him. I love how much of his character is built around his ability to think his way out of situations, but also how that intelligence doesn’t magically make him immune to consequences (that poor man suffered those consequences). There is something incredibly satisfying about following a character whose greatest weapon is his mind, especially when the story is clever enough to keep you guessing alongside him.

The prologue was also one of my favourite parts of the book and one of the best prologues I read in fantasy. It gives us a glimpse of the person Locke is becoming, the world that shaped him, and the kind of story we’re about to explore. It made me invested in Locke from the beginning, and I loved how the book gradually built on that foundation.

Now, I also want to talk about something that has nothing to do with whether this book deserves five stars, because it absolutely does, but everything to do with how we talk about fantasy and female representation.

One of the criticisms I often make when discussing fantasy books is the lack of female characters, or the way women are sometimes written as though they are an afterthought in worlds supposedly populated by entire civilizations. And whenever I bring this up, there is almost always someone (usually a man) rushing to explain why the absence of women is actually justified. Apparently, women don’t need to be present because the story is about war, or politics, or mercenaries, or a group of male protagonists. Apparently, the author had no reason to include them. Apparently, every absence has a perfectly reasonable explanation, and I should stop asking questions.

And this is where The Lies of Locke Lamora becomes such an interesting example.

This book has an overwhelmingly male main cast. The Gentlemen Bastards are men, the relationships at the centre of the story are predominantly between men, and the narrative follows their experiences. I have absolutely no problem with that. I don’t need every book to have a perfectly balanced cast, and I don’t think every story needs to be structured around female characters to be worthwhile.

But what I found interesting is that, despite the predominantly male cast, women are present throughout Camorr. They exist in different social environments and professions. They are part of the world rather than appearing exclusively when the plot requires a love interest, a victim, a mother, or a convenient source of motivation for a male character. The city doesn’t suddenly become a place without women simply because the protagonists happen to be men.

And to me, that is the point.

There is a difference between writing a story about men and writing a world in which women barely seem to exist.

Of course, the presence of women alone doesn’t automatically mean that a book has excellent female representation. Visibility isn’t the same as complexity, agency, or meaningful characterisation, and I don’t want to pretend those are interchangeable. But acknowledging women’s existence across the world you have built is a starting point, especially for a book released in 2006!!

And honestly, I think this is where some of the defensiveness around criticism of female representation becomes particularly frustrating. When I point out that a book lacks women, I am not necessarily saying that the author is sexist, that the book is terrible, or that every story must follow a particular formula. I am making an observation about the world the author chose to create. We can appreciate a book’s strengths and still discuss the limitations of its representation. Those two things are not mutually exclusive.

Anyway, back to the actual review before I turn this into an essay about gender and speculative fiction (although, let’s be honest, I could absolutely do that).

This book was such a joy to read. I loved its characters, its atmosphere and the way it balances its more playful moments with genuine darkness. I loved spending time in Camorr, and I loved how invested I became in the Gentlemen Bastards and their relationships. Most importantly, I finished it feeling like I had experienced a complete, wonderfully constructed story while also wanting to spend considerably more time in this world.

Five stars, absolutely. Scott Lynch, you have my attention. And if the rest of the series is anything like this, I have a feeling the Gentlemen Bastards and I are going to have a very long relationship.