3/5 (5,14/10)
Honestly, the book fulfills its promise: to be a vulgar and more adult copy of childish magic stories like Harry Potter and Narnia. I would add that it is more logical regarding magic, but from the third part onwards, it stops being so and becomes a strange paranoia of the author.
In itself, the story is not bad -the lore is too convoluted for my taste, yes-, but in my opinion it should have been a standalone, and not a trilogy. There is not much to stretch about the story itself to have ended up being a trilogy.
One of the big problems of the book is the characters. Yes, I understand that they are a more "teenage and dark" version of Harry Potter, but when you make characters that you don't like, they are useless. At no point can you really get to like any of them -except Alice-, and the fact that they are constantly talking about sex, insults, vulgar actions -and movements- and the fact that they are so uncharismatic, makes the reading become heavy at times (Quentin is an a*hole!). Also, the story lacks a good villain. The villain is not scary, despite his mysterious aura in his first appearance. But if at the end of everything you reveal something very important and significant about his childhood, how do you expect us to hate the villain? He is not revealed as someone horrible either: he lacks intimidation and fear.
This book is helped by the fact that the narrative is fast and light, but it sacrifices the quality of the narration: it is simple and not serious. It fails to convey emotions, even in sentimental, important moments and in battle.
It is between "meh" and "not bad", but I would not read it again and I am not going to continue with the trilogy.
