Skip to content

This may have been one of the best books I've read in 2024.

I have a mostly love (sometimes a lil hate) relationship for Abby Jimenez books. A lot of times they work for me, but there is always SOMETHING that rubs me the wrong way.

But this book? No notes. She was great and left me longing for more and wanting to hold each of these characters.

First, was this insta-lovey? Yeah, a bit. Did it turn me off? No, because that was part of the charm.

The whole premise of this book is that Justin didn't know "the one" because he never felt like he'd been hit by a truck - so for him to feel that instantly with Emma? Fitting.

Emma, oh Emma. I FEEL for characters with unreliable mothers (trauma) and watching Emma battle her love for her mother and how everyone else felt about Amber made me FEEL for her. It's like watching a car crash, you know you should look away but you're invested. Seeing Emma's realizations, making herself small made me want to hug her. But the way that she loved Justin's siblings? How she was able to open up to Justin made me so proud!

Third act break ups can usually be a hit or miss for me - but this was done perfectly, I don't even know if I can say it was a break up. I wish we had a little built more time in that era (shocking) but I still think it was a great resolution to the story.

Ugh, overall I love them your honor.