It wasn't bad, it just didn't make me feral
Catch the Sun by Jennifer Hartmann was my first book by this author, and I went into it with HIGH expectations. I had heard so many good things about her books that I was fully prepared to have my heart ripped out, stomped on, handed back to me and somehow be grateful for the experience.
Instead… my heart remained suspiciously intact.
I didn't love this book, but I didn't hate it either. It landed firmly in that awkward “yeah, it was good” territory where you finish the book, close it, and just kind of… carry on with your day.
There were things I liked. The story had cosy, nostalgic feeling to it, and I liked the connection between Max and Ella and the idea of two people finding their way back to each other. There were emotional and heavier moments woven throughout, but for some reason they just didn't hit me as hard as I expected them to.
At times, the story felt a little bland. Not bad. Not boring enough that I wanted to stop reading. Just missing that something that makes me completely obsessed and has me neglecting basic responsibilities because apparently fictional people's problems are now more important than my own.
Maybe my expectations were simply too high going in. Sometimes being told repeatedly that an author is going to emotionally destroy you is basically the literary equivalent of someone saying, “This is the funniest video you'll ever see.” Now you've set the bar in the stratosphere and I'm sitting here waiting to be impressed.
3 stars - A cosy, emotional read that I liked but didn't fall in love with.
That said, I'm definitely not writing Jennifer Hartmann off yet. This was only my first book by her, and I've heard far too many people rave about her other stories to give up after one lukewarm experience.
So Jennifer… I'll be back.
I'm still waiting for the emotional damage everyone promised me.
