I liked the concept but not the execution. At all. I don't know, I felt like I needed more. I didn't really get any baddie vibes from the Villain. He came off as more of kids Disney channel villain. What was the point of magic if he never even used it? What could be even do? He was always almost losing. Evie frustrated me because she was always injured. I don't know, that just bothers me. Every other page she was getting healed. I did like her relationship with her sister. The poor girl did get ignored mostly. They hardly spent any time together at all.
It was interesting enough that I didn't quit, I kept waiting for it to get juicy. So imagine my surprise when it ended on a cliffhanger!! A cliffhanger! Forget book two. Trim the boring stuff from this book and finish your storyline in book one! Two stars because overall I didn't hate it, but I was not impressed. It was just ok.
